Tesla Model Y vs. the 2025 Electric SUV Field: Which Compact EV Rules the Road?
The compact electric SUV segment has exploded heading into 2025. Just a few years ago the Tesla Model Y essentially stood alone, but today it battles half‑a‑dozen credible rivals. MotorTrend’s 2025 “EV SUV Big Test” pits a refreshed dual‑motor Model Y against the Hyundai Ioniq 5, Kia EV6, Ford Mustang Mach‑E, Toyota bZ4X, Chevrolet Equinox EV and Volkswagen ID4. Power outputs range from 320 horsepower for the Korean entries to 397 hp for the Tesla, while torque spans 389–500 lb‑ft, ensuring all of these compact EVs are quick off the line.
Driving Dynamics and Range
MotorTrend testers were impressed by how the 2025 Model Y’s retuned suspension makes it comfortable yet still engaging to drive. Its quick steering gives it a sporty feel, though the Mach‑E was the group’s outright handling champ thanks to its firm suspension and strong lateral grip. The Kia EV6 strikes a sporty balance, while the Ioniq 5 delivers the smoothest, quietest ride among the bunch. Range remains a prime differentiator: the Kia EV6 topped MotorTrend’s 70‑mph road‑trip test at 266 miles, beating the Equinox EV (262 mi), Mustang Mach‑E and Model Y (both 252 mi). The Ioniq 5 covered 234 miles, while Toyota’s bZ4X and VW’s ID4 were last with 222 and 208 miles, respectively.
Charging and Features
Fast‑charging performance matters as much as range. The EV6 added 160 miles of range in just 15 minutes on a 350 kW charger; the Ioniq 5 added 138 miles in the same time, while the Model Y trailed slightly at 133 miles. The refreshed Model Y counters with a new rear‑seat entertainment screen, powered folding seats and a third climate zone, giving it the most rear legroom and infotainment flexibility in the group. Buyers looking for the smoothest ride may prefer the Hyundai or Kia, while those prioritizing handling might favour the Mach‑E. Overall, Tesla still holds a strong position thanks to its charging network and over‑the‑air software updates.
Verdict
For 2025 the compact EV field has never been tougher. The 2025 Model Y is improved and competitive, but the Hyundai Ioniq 5 and Kia EV6 offer smoother rides and faster charging. Buyers should weigh handling, ride quality, charging speed and interior space to determine the best fit. Regardless of choice, the competition is driving innovation and giving consumers more electric‑SUV options than ever before.
